Terry Purcell has seen the manager-selection process from every seat, a Connecticut pension fund, a $20 billion fund of funds, and now Longwall Family Office, where emerging and specialist managers are a feature, not a risk. In this conversation he lays out how Longwall actually qualifies hedge funds, why personal capital commitment matters more than pedigree, and where managers quietly disqualify themselves.
“Emerging managers should spend a lot of time on their DDQs.”
— Terry Purcell
Produced from the audio of this episode and cleaned for readability — no wording was changed. Guests state their own figures and opinions on the record; those statements belong to the speaker, not to the show or its host.
Jennifer Bruno
Welcome to Hedge Interview, the essential listen for private fund managers committed to operational excellence. This episode provides an inside look at the manager due diligence and selection process at Longwall Investment Partners, a multifamily office located in Lake Forest, Illinois, and Westport, Connecticut. My guest today is Terry Purcell. He is a partner and co-chief investment officer at Longwall, where he applies three decades of experience in direct investing, allocating, and consulting in alternative and traditional investments across private and public sectors. Terry has also been the head of portfolio management at a $20 billion fund of funds, and he oversaw private equity and alternative investments at a $45 billion Connecticut pension fund. Thank you for joining me today, Terry.
Terry Purcell
Thanks for having me.
Jennifer Bruno
So tell me first about your experience at Long Wall.
Terry Purcell
Sure, Jennifer. Thank you. Long Wall is a multifamily office focused on investments. It started as a single-family office about three years ago. We're growing. We have a handful of families now, and we're expecting to onboard a few more in the coming quarters, and we have a small team, but a very experienced team that has a lot of experience, particularly in alternative investments, which we think is is you know a differentiating factor from you know a lot of other small family offices and and wealth management groups. So things are going quite well, and you know we're growing.
Jennifer Bruno
How about your prior experience? You have extensive experience in the fund, private fund management world. So tell us about that.
Terry Purcell
Sure. You know I've been on the buy side pretty much my entire career. I've been an invest career career long investment management person. Started as a fundamental analyst at Mitchell Hutchins, which was Payne Wavers Asset Management Company. Ended up running two hedge funds. Got started really in the hedge fund space, the alternative investment space, in the late 90s. So it's been quite a while. Ran two. Ended up transitioning to be an allocator about 12 years ago now, so I was I was appointed to the position you mentioned at Connecticut's pension fund in 2012, and it was a phenomenal role that included not only overseeing hedge fund investments but also, as you mentioned, private equity, venture capital, real assets, opportunistic. It was really multifaceted. It was a it was it was wonderful position, and that's a that's an office that's still near and dear to my heart. And then and then I went to to Permal as you mentioned, which was $20 billion fund of funds, predominantly hedge fund of funds, and I sat on the global investment committee. So I guess at that point, you know, I had a lot of hedge fund experience, so it's logical that it is one of the focus areas or the building blocks for the investment process we have at Long Wall.
Jennifer Bruno
And you've seen the the whole, you know, fund management industry evolve over time. So, what would you say is is different today than what it was 10 or 20 years ago.
Terry Purcell
Sure, I think the financial crisis in '08 had a big impact. I think that it caused a lot of pressure, particularly in the hedge fund industry, to kind of institutionalize, and there were good aspects and bad aspects to it. I think that the most significant change, though, is it really kind of brought in risk taking or reduced risk taking for a lot of managers. And you know that's not necessarily positive for an allocator. You want your managers to be basically pursuing the investment strategy that you know they've done well for a long time. On the flip side, it you know the changes in the pressure increase transparency in the industry, so that's a very good thing for allocators, obviously, to have a much better sense of what managers are doing and what are in the portfolios.
Jennifer Bruno
And how about your your manager qualification process? Is that similar to the process that you used when you were at the fund of funds, or has that evolved as well?
Terry Purcell
No, it's a great question. It hasn't changed a great deal. You know, my personal bent and ours collectively at Longwall is for managers with you know significant experience. In some cases, that might be a manager that has run their hedge fund firm for you know 10 to 15 years. In some cases, it may be a fairly new firm. It could be it could be you know an an emerging manager. But in that case, really you know what we want to see is obviously good transparency of. Manager, his or her results from you know wherever they came from, the shop they were last at, and obviously are looking for managers that are pursuing the same strategy that they were doing then and did quite well. So you know we we we we can do both, but they are they they do tend to be managers that have you know a fair amount of experience. So sorry, go ahead.
Jennifer Bruno
So, for emerging managers, what would pique your interest? What are the elements that get you excited about an emerging manager?
Terry Purcell
Well, I mean, you know, I've always been partial to emerging managers. A lot of great performance, obviously, as you know, comes early in in a fund's life cycle, so if you look across the roster of managers at Longwell, you're not going to see any really large hedge funds. There are cases where size does become the enemy of performance, so there's nothing wrong with being an emerging manager. But the kind of things that we would look for have to do in addition to you know track record verification I just mentioned have to do with the business that they're setting up and so we would want to see you know really well known service providers that they have hired whether it be the prime broker the administrator, the legal counsel, etc. and you know we we can know really quickly by looking at those names. You know if their names we know or not. Also, want to look at you know the internal infrastructure that that is being put in place at at the fund manager in terms of both people and you know the appropriate investments in technology and you know, it's important to us. You know, it won't surprise you that we want the manager to have a significant percentage of their liquid net worth in in the fund. You know, we want our clients to truly, you know, have alignment of interest with the managers that they're nvested with and be investing alongside them, so that's very important to us. You you would find that at all of our managers, and they're they're they're just a few. You know, I can go into more, but they're they're they're kind of right off the bat. You really need to check those boxes for us to to I think proceed with due diligence.
Jennifer Bruno
And do you expect a fee structure that's more palatable, given that they're less experienced, that they have less of a track record? I've been seeing that myself more often, so I'm wondering if that's your experience as well.
Terry Purcell
I think I think we've been seeing a little bit of fee compression. I would say we don't lead with it. You want to see standard terms, and frankly, I think a lot of large allocators, and and and we were this way in Connecticut when when I was there, you know, want to back our emerging managers and understand that you know they have to pay their people, they have to turn the lights on before the the assets reach a certain size, so we're not really you know outside of maybe a seeding model or something like that. I don't think there's there's a lot of pressure to on on emerging managers. There should be a lot of pressure on emerging managers to cut fees later on the life cycle. You know, yes, then I think we could talk about it. We you know, but I I personally particularly seen it a lot on the private equity side, where you know when a fund reaches Fund Five, Fund Six vintage, and you know they've raised billions and billions, you may see you know some some fee reductions. But you know it's not something we'd lead with at all for an emerging manager to to overfocus on on fees. We we want to know what the net returns that you deliver for you know our clients are going to be
Jennifer Bruno
right, and how do you source managers, emerging or established?
Terry Purcell
Multiple ways. You know, we each have internally. We each have, as I've mentioned, a long history of vetting managers. So you know, there's there's there's you know pre-existing body of managers that we know. We you know do speak with prime brokers. We go to you know what we consider are the most important couple prime broker capital introduction conferences that happen each year. And what are
Jennifer Bruno
those? Wait, what are those? Well, I
Terry Purcell
mean, I I personally spend time in January at iConnections down in Florida for the first time. That's a
Jennifer Bruno
good one.
Terry Purcell
Which is which is a high volume, you know, opportunity to to see managers of a lot of different strategies. You know, we're fortunate to have good relationships with both Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, who run great conferences each year. Some of them locally to us here, so it's convenient. So you know, when when going going back to the the comments I made about being with really top tier service providers, obviously those are, and you know. If you see a manager that's using managers like that and a few others as their prime broker, you know it gives some comfort certainly versus a manager that's using a prime that you never heard of.
Jennifer Bruno
Right, right. And what's your typical allocation size?
Terry Purcell
I think you know I think our largest right now to a single fund is somewhere between five and 10 million, but we've typically started at about $2 million, and you know that's obviously now growing and going, growing, going to grow as as as long wall grows. So it's not not terribly significant, but you know we're with managers that are you know in many cases, 300, 500, $700 million in assets across the firm, where they're you know a phenomenal manager who, in addition to having a a a majority of his or her net worth in the fund, is also not spending a ton of time out on the road marketing. So you know these are these are not you know like I mentioned the the really big shops. These are more you know funds that in a lot of cases you know you probably haven't heard of. So we're not an insignificant investor, and and hopefully we're going to get bigger with them as we grow.
Jennifer Bruno
And is there an AUM size that is sort of like a a bare minimum that you require for an emerging manager.
Terry Purcell
It's not a hard and fast one. Obviously, you know between you know when when you get to 100 and and some million dollars, that's when you register with the SEC. That's obviously a nice checkbox or or a nice milestone. We at Long Wall registered with the SEC last year, and so that's helpful, but no, I don't think there's there's really you know a hard and fast threshold. You have to look fund by fund at the liquidity of strategy and what the capacity is, and you have to think about a lot of you know different variables in terms of finding an ideal AUM size. More importantly, I think you know. I'd advise merging managers to spend you know a lot of time on their DDQs. That's a really important aspect, particularly for for small farm managers. We get a ton of information there, particularly about the operations and you know mechanical things that are outside you know the investment process, like money movements and service providers, and you know policies and procedures that have been put in place. So I you know we spend a ton of time combing through DDQs of managers that we're you know seriously vetting. So I would recommend you know taking that that component of it very seriously.
Jennifer Bruno
At what stage do you look at the DDQ? Do you request it?
Terry Purcell
Well, we're when we're you know significantly considering it. We we will have met with the manager certainly at least once, probably multiple times, possibly have seen you know a general presentation they've made at a conference. You know, in certain cases we've we've looked at managers that had been working with one of the the the top tier placement agents in in the country. So we know in those cases that a lot of operational due diligence has been done. We know somebody else is is vetting this manager alongside us. So you know right away that placement agent would would give us the DDQ and and and all the materials. So, you know, it's it's it's stage two or stage three. Obviously, it starts with looking at the marketing materials, better known as the deck. And you know, it's important to have a good deck. But we will focus again on on kind of the track record, the history, the consistency of how the investment strategy has been managed by by that manager,
Jennifer Bruno
and how long do you look at a manager before you allocate? What's your sort of life cycle of evaluation?
Terry Purcell
You know, we're only a three-year-old firm, so I don't want to generalize too much, but you know it's it's significant. You know we pride ourselves on being fundamental analysts, and and and we do the research. So we spend time with the manager before committing, you know, our family clients money. So you know there's there's never been an investment we've made that was shorter than you know a few months certainly in duration, and and we're invested with you know several managers that you know my partner's known for many many years, and and and the due diligence started you know five seven years ago, but you know we at Longwell didn't make our first investment in them until you know mid 22,
Jennifer Bruno
and are there specific strategies that you like more than others?
Terry Purcell
I I wouldn't say that. I think that you know that changes with the market environment. You know, alongside. Running our clients' portfolios and and and and customizing our clients' portfolios, we also run have started a small internal hedge fund of funds. So we have multiple places that we can use a hedge fund manager in our investment broader investment portfolio. If you look at that fund of funds, we we have a variety of strategies. We have several equity strategies, but you really wouldn't find any of them being just a plain vanilla long short equity manager that does you know every single sector. We tend to we tend to like specialists. You know, it could be a sector specialist, a single sector, or you know maybe two to three, and then we have non-equity strategies. Alongside that, we you know we we we love uncorrelated managers. If you look at that portfolio, we we not only have managers who are uncorrelated to public markets, but managers who are highly uncorrelated to each other. We've invested in an agricultural commodity specialist. We've invested with an emerging manager rates specialist. You know, again, we've we've invest. We we have a specialized Asian manager. We invested with a with a healthcare sector specialist. So they don't correlate with each other, and and that's a good thing. So you know, it really depends on on what you're seeing in the environment. But you know, they tend to have even if they're not pure sector specialists, they tend to have a very tight investment focus, and they are not go anywhere strategies. We know exactly what they're doing. It's it's it's in our view a repeatable strategy, and you know if if a client asked me or my partner what you know a particular manager that we invested with does we we know that we can answer that you know in in 15 seconds and we should be able to so if if if it's a strategy we don't really understand or we don't see the consistency of the returns in the past-it's-it's probably not a manager that we would continue betting.
Jennifer Bruno
Are you considering any sort of new areas like blockchain, digital assets, AI? You know, the new kids on the block.
Terry Purcell
Well, you know, we're a small firm, so we're not doing a ton yet in the digital space, but kind of everybody's doing AI, right? So AI is touching everything at the moment. We're not necessarily looking at managers or specializing it, but we're spending a lot of time with managers that you know are are educating us as to how it's going to impact their companies, and so we have investments with managers who you know are both long and short kind of companies that will be affected by AI, both beneficiaries and potential losers. So it's it's it's absolutely a a pervasive theme. You know, obviously one of the other things that's changed in the last two years, along with AI, has been you know the interest rate cycle. So for for 15 years, you know you didn't really have to think a ton about fixed income with rates near zero, but that changed in a hurry, obviously. So spent a lot of time in the last you know 18 to 21 months with credit managers and and understanding how how they manage, particularly long short credit managers, and you know I think our house view would be that rates are not going back to to that zero neighborhood anytime soon. So you know these opportunities to to profit in credit, particularly from dispersion in credit products, will will persist for a while.
Jennifer Bruno
Right, and so for managers that are looking to sort of get in front of you, would they be better served to go, you know, to try to get in front of placement agents or prime brokerage first?
Terry Purcell
No, you know, when I mentioned placement agent issue, that was just that was happenstance in a couple cases. We source most directly. Most do not work with a placement agent. And like I said, we you know we're at conferences. We are you know included on a lot of companies, firms you know marketing distribution lists. We have prior relationships, like I mentioned. So so there's a variety of ways, but I think that you know the best way tends to be to reach out directly to to allocators such as us, and I think the most effective you know way to stand out is to pretty quickly be able to espouse the the differentiators in in your investment strategy. You know, it's it's you see a lot of long short equity. So you know that's harder to right away be able to say here's how this manager is different than the you know than the last 10 we've seen. So you know, particularly with somebody like us that that loves kind of tight investment processes, if not sector specialists, it's really able. It's really. You know, beneficial to be able to espouse your differentiators right up front, so that you stand out from the pile of of decks, and and can you know we continue on looking at you.
Jennifer Bruno
That's I'm glad you said it because I tell managers that all the time. Right. No, it
Terry Purcell
is what it is. The you know, there's there's there's a lot, and any a typical allocator obviously will not end up allocating to the vast majority of funds external fund managers that they look at. So you know, it's it's really important to to to kind of put a thought in the allocator's head early on as to what your position would be in that allocator's portfolio,
Jennifer Bruno
right. And so, what are some mistakes, like a no-no, like common mistakes that you see that that are just like that's a no.
Terry Purcell
You know, doing the other side of the things I've just mentioned, we tend to focus on. So, you know, consistency of of the application of the strategy very key. So you know, if we see a manager that is is succumbing to that age-old term style drift, you know, that's immediately going to raise flags. We're going to dig into that. That's really never never a positive. We'd rather a manager that consistently applies their investment strategy across environments. Obviously, they want to adapt. My my partner and I spoke just yesterday afternoon on a video call with one of the managers we've invested in. We catch up, you know, very frequently, periodically, and you know, really, he was able to espouse to us his views on the market right now, his views on what's going on economically in terms of uncertainty over inflation and interest rates, changes he's made in the portfolio. So when we hung up the call, we had a very good sense of how he was positioned, how he was thinking, and it's a difficult environment right now. But he's doing the same thing he was doing last year, three years ago, five years ago, in terms of his core investment strategy, so that's a that's a really big plus. So I would I would I would you know highlight style drift as as you know kind of the as you said a no no,
Jennifer Bruno
right, and so what would be the the the most important slides that you hone in on in a pitch deck. Like, what's the what's the meat that you're the stake of it that you're you want to get to?
Terry Purcell
You know, the manager's bio and track record. You know, where have they been doing this? Like I mentioned, it could be at this shop, you know, that exists right now for 15 years. It could be that this shop was formed last year, but we know what that manager did and how they did it, you know, in the prior in the prior years. The track record, obviously, looking on a compounded basis is important. Looking at three-year, five-year numbers, but also kind of the consistency of the track record. So was there one year that was a crazy huge, you know, return year that has carried you know their five-year numbers or something like that? That would be you know less favorable to us than seeing more consistency to their returns. And also, you're right away going to look at the periods where they struggled. So when they were in a market environment that was not conducive for their particular strategy, how did they protect capital? You know, did they did they did they make their bad year be something where they were able to hang around the flat line, or was their bad year you know trending as far away from the flat line as it did in good years, you know, on the upside. So, you know, we'd love to see that that asymmetry where managers know when markets are conducive to their strategy, and they're able to, you know, put the risk in the book and generate positive numbers, but also basically dial it back and potentially be a little defensive when they know the market is is is going the other way for their strategy.
Jennifer Bruno
I remember I came out of the CTA space myself and was an asset raiser. And after 2008, every deck, every every institution that we I was in front of wanted to see a slide on risk management balance. Oh, what's our risk management process? Like, we need to get that together. That became a really big deal at that point. Maybe it's you know, it's it's kind of common at this point back then, and
Terry Purcell
that pressure led to you know the significant rise in the managed account you know concept. So you know, managed account platforms really rose. There was a lot of pressure after '08 and and made off, and a lot of it stems from European investors first. And so, from all one example, we had you know nearly 50% of our assets while I was there on managed accounts. So you have the the visibility into risk management. So you know transfer. Hency of of the process is is key,
Jennifer Bruno
right? Right, that makes perfect sense. And so, without naming names, is there like a manager success story, like somebody that blew you away, like wow? Anybody that really impressed you according to how they've put together their operation.
Terry Purcell
I mean, not to give you a non-answer, but there've been many. You know, I think that we long will have looked. You know, we've had I think about 125 manager meetings just in the past year, whether it be at conferences or you know one-on-ones in their offices or even you know Zoom calls like yesterday. And so we've seen a lot of managers. When you add up the years, I think that the success stories are, particularly in the emerging manager category, are the managers that not only you know come out of the gate and start with strong performance records, but put the infrastructure and the right things in place to run their company, because it's very difficult to run a portfolio and a company at the same time. And I speak for experience as somebody that started a hedge fund. It's very difficult. So to me, a success story is a manager that is not only you know generating good numbers and and you know pursuing their strategy and has great risk management product process and all that on the investment side, but has put the proper infrastructure, like I mentioned earlier, in place on the business and operational side. Whether it be the CFO, a risk officer, you know, operations, compliance, the whole thing-they're all very important, and it's it can be very distracting. So to me, the success stories are the managers that did both. They grew their assets to you know a threshold level with good performance. Maybe new assets you know came in that were attracted by their performance, but they also built a company that's going to last. You know, and you can see that it's going to last. It's built to last for a lot of years. As as as an example, you know, at Long Wall we actually have a couple of family clients that also decided to become shareholders in our business. So I think it speaks volumes to kind of the partnership that you know culture that we're looking to create with clients, and you really want to see that at a manager as well. You want to see a manager doing things that imply that he or she tends to be there for a long time and build build an enduring business. Because obviously, the hedge fund the hedge fund business is littered, you know, with with managers that were around for three years or less, and in many of the cases, Jennifer, as you know, it wasn't the majority of the cases. I think were not necessarily performance related, but they're operational, and they they didn't put the right things in place. So yes, I think that I think that to me the success stories are the managers that have put that infrastructure in place. They've outsourced to smart people around them, those those non-investment functions that lets them focus on the portfolio because that's where our clients' money is, and that's what we care about having them do every day.
Jennifer Bruno
Right, right. Having you know, working capital is is essential, and yeah, which goes back
Terry Purcell
which goes back to the the discussion about you know not being trying to be a fee cutter to to emerging managers, right? You you you want to partner with them. You you you make an investment hoping obviously that you're going to be in there for multiple years. So you care how this business does, and so yes, I think that these these things all kind of go hand in glove, and so you know we do not focus on trying to be a price cutter. We'd rather focus on the manager, like you said, having enough capital to put these things in place.
Jennifer Bruno
Right, and so what are you excited about for the rest of this year? What are trends or just things you're keeping an eye on in general could be in a macro sense or otherwise.
Terry Purcell
There's a lot to keep an eye on right now. You know, obviously geopolitical. We've got we've got more going on around the globe than we have in a while. Unfortunately, those can have an impact at any given moment, even on U.S. markets, the political there's there's an election coming up. You know, we're told so that's pretty that's kind of something that's hovering over the markets, and then just this general uncertainty that's been hanging around now for you know a few months about where inflation is really headed and and what the interest rate cycle is going to be. So we have been of the mind that you know interest rates would be like I mentioned earlier somewhat higher for longer. They're not going back to zero. And so it was it was a little baffling the the the market reaction after Powell's comments on December. 13th about you know expected rate cuts and the market kind of really ran with it and there's a lot of euphoria that has totally gone the other way now that that you know if that was a risk that was in the market of disappointment on when we we when and how big we will get on the rate cuts I think that's gone. There are people now, literally just as of this week, talking about might the next move be an interest rate hike. So that's a big deal. That's a big deal to the credit space. That is a big deal to small cap companies and really all growth companies that are, you know, to some degree, their valuation, their P/E mobile, is really a function of interest rates because it's it's discounted earnings and growth companies obviously have you know a lot of their big projected earnings out in the future. So you know what happens here with rate the path of rates is absolutely you know a focus for us. But again, we're not we're not expecting a ton to happen anytime soon. There's obviously a lot of of economic strength, so you know we'd like to invest in areas, sectors, companies, managers that are able to take advantage of that economic strength, and/or you know are are uncorrelated enough that regardless of what kind of market movement we get the rest of the year, they can deliver an attractive absolute return because it's going to be a choppy year. You know, there's going to we're seeing it right now. You know, we've just seen about a 5% drawdown in public in public stocks just in the past week or week and a half. You know, I wouldn't be surprised. We would not be surprised at all to see several of those this year,
Jennifer Bruno
right? And so, what? How many allocations do you make in a year typically to fund managers?
Terry Purcell
It depends on how many you know attractive managers you find that that meet all your criteria. We're incredibly selective. I think so far we've made about 13 to 15 allocations. so we're not, you know, spreading it really all around. We like to focus on kind of our best ideas. We we run client portfolios that way to be, you know, not as they say, diversified or over over diversified. And so, on a manager selection basis, we're the same way. There's a hurdle you have to climb. You know that all those boxes. You know I've mentioned in the last few minutes. So it depends on how many managers come across. You know our radar screen that meet all those. It could be you know one a quarter. It could be three a quarter. It's it's hard to say, and it's a function of you know what we're interested in maybe tilting towards or investing in thematically, you know, in terms of exposures we want for our client portfolios, and secondarily for you know the fund we run internally. So it's it's hard to put an answer on it, but you know it's it's it's not you know 15 a year. It's more selective than that.
Jennifer Bruno
Right, right. As it should be. You have to be careful.
Terry Purcell
I agree.
Jennifer Bruno
Well, Terry, thank you so much for all of your insights. This is really, really helpful. I know that emerging managers are always kind of wanting to understand the allocation process and you know best practices, what to do, what not to do. So I really appreciate your time today.
Terry Purcell
Absolutely, I appreciate you having me.
Managers, allocators, advisors: episodes are 30 relaxed minutes, recorded remotely, and made to share.
Pitch yourself as a guestOne email when each episode drops: the story, the best line, and the listen link.
Subscribe