capital firsthand.

Home  /  Episodes

Service Provider Spotlight

Scott Treloar

Co-Founder & CEO, Noviscient & FundBox.AI

March 2024 · 36 min

Launching a fund in a month, not a year.

Scott Treloar is rebuilding fund infrastructure from first principles. FundBox.AI compresses what traditionally takes six to twelve months, registration, setup, launch, into roughly one, at a fraction of the conventional cost. A conversation about the digital operating model for fund management, the pitfalls that trap new managers, and what digitally-connected infrastructure means for the manager-investor relationship.

In this conversation

  • The digital operating model for modern fund management
  • Launching in ~1 month vs. the traditional 6–12
  • Where new managers overspend and underbuild
  • Trade-level data, analytics, and investor transparency

Transcript

Produced from the audio of this episode and cleaned for readability — no wording was changed. Guests state their own figures and opinions on the record; those statements belong to the speaker, not to the show or its host.

5,780 words · 46 exchanges

Jennifer Bruno

Welcome to Hedge Interview. This episode is part of the Service Provider Spotlight series, which features insights from important financial service providers that support fund management. My guest today is Scott Trelor. He is the co-founder and CEO of Noviscient, based in Singapore. Noviscient helps emerging fund managers set up and operate non-U.S. sorry domiciled funds through their Fundbox AI platform. Scott has 20 years of financial markets experience. Before co-founding Noviscient, Scott was a portfolio manager at Volpe's investment management, and before that, he headed up a quant team within Deutsche Bank's Singapore trading business. He also spent several years in venture capital at Macquarie Bank. Welcome, Scott.

Scott Treloar

Thanks, Jennifer. Glad to be here.

Jennifer Bruno

Great. First, tell me about your inspiration for co-founding Novicient,

Scott Treloar

right? So Noviscient, we identified while I was working at Devors, what we identified was it's increasingly hard for emerging managers to get started. So emerging hedge fund managers, rules and regulations, expectations are kind of getting higher. Institutions expect more robust infrastructure, and so what that meant was emerging managers really needed a sort of larger AUM to get started. And so they would, you know, typically say, "I'd like to start a hedge fund. They would go to a prime broker or an administrator, and they would say, "That's great. We love. We'd love to help you. Have you got 50 or $100 million in seed funding? And the manager normally says, "No, I don't have that, and they sort of go away. And that's really we think it's a function of hedge funds still operating as a cottage industry, the same way they've sort of operated since last century, in essence, and and so we think with technology and platforms we can sort of open up a new way and start to provide a better way for managers to get started and in particular to get access to to investor capital.

Jennifer Bruno

And when you say get started, you mean in Europe primarily, or you know in what regions?

Scott Treloar

No. So our emerging managers can start can be anywhere. Basically, they our model is we will set up a fund vehicle. Fund vehicle is actually domiciled or based under Singapore's VCC structure, but the managers can be anywhere, and so we'll have managers based out of Europe, out of the US, out of Asia. Even got one that we're hoping to start out of South Africa, so that will be our first one from that continent. So, but essentially, because they can send trading strategies and signals through to us via the internet, they can be based anywhere.

Jennifer Bruno

But where does that mean that they are targeting? Is this basically where are they? This registration allows them to target investor. Yeah, investors on that side of

Scott Treloar

it. So in. can really come from anywhere. So our existing funds will have investors out of Asia and out of Europe. US is always a little complex because there's sort of a tax complication, but not insurmountable. We just need to set up a feeder fund. So investors similarly can can come from from anywhere. And

Jennifer Bruno

that was my next question: Is how is this different from setting up a master feeder fund, or is it

Scott Treloar

the same? No, sort of similar. the The vehicle is the vehicle, but what you, but if you set up, you say your own hedge fund, regulators and investors will sort of expect you to have a full team: operations, compliance, legal, marketing. They'll expect you to be managing your broker relationships. And what tends to happen is the managers who should be focusing more on the trading, spend all their time running a business, and in a sense, being a good trader and running a good business-not necessarily the same skill set. In fact, almost almost no overlap. So what you really want is then to be focusing on the trading, and to in a sense outsource. And so so we're in a platform, and we will look after all of that from client onboarding all the way through to investor reporting. And we're a little different in that we are a very we operate what I'll call a digital operating model, which means it's really information streams, which allows us to keep the costs very low. Transparency for investors and for the managers, high and and managers risk effectively.

Jennifer Bruno

And how were you able to put this together? How did the technology change such that you could make this available?

Scott Treloar

Right. So I think I mean the strength is really to come from a clean sheet. If you're kind of coming already from existing infrastructure and technology and people and processes, you'll find there's a lot of spreadsheets and there's a lot of checklists and there's a lot of people with who know what to do in their heads. And really, what we're trying to do is actually let's start afresh. Let's understand what you really need to do. Let's increasingly digitize. We're kind of pushing Excel spreadsheets out. We're trying to push PDFs out. We're trying to bring a whole lot of it online. And so we just spent the last five years essentially building, starting the first few managers, learning how to make things increasingly efficient. Working out how to work with emerging managers because you know they've got their own challenges, they've got their own objectives. They want to be successful, and you know as you speak to them, what you sort of find is, is you know they'll say, "Listen, I just want to do this thing. Whether it's it could be also work with say some VC managers. They want to get out and find good deals and execute, and then help those companies succeed. Succeed. What they don't want to do is be running around looking after sort of investor reporting and doing all the paperwork for running a fund. Similarly, traders ought to be-you know-the really good traders ought to be spending all their time trading. But instead, what's happening is they're spending-you know-50% of their time or more marketing trying to figure out how to get capital in. And what that what that means is it becomes, firstly, on a you know a standalone hedge fund, you have this cost base that is just painful to absorb. It shortens your life. If you've really outsourced a lot of those costs, so you know we'll operate a fund at 20 to 25% of what a standalone fund would cost. You just have a lot longer to generate a track record to prove to investors that you're that you're that you're able to deliver excess returns at alpha. So it just it's specialization in a sense, right? Traders and BC groups should be doing what they should be doing. Operations compliance legal is sort of a matter of efficiencies and scale economies, and and doing things well, and repeating those processes, and separate separation actually adds a lot of value.

Jennifer Bruno

Right, and do you work with specific types of asset managers, or all types? Size-wise, I understand probably smaller ones are an optimal fit for this offering, but what are there any strategy types, or does that not matter?

Scott Treloar

Doesn't matter too much. So we we will. I mean, we sort of focused, or certainly started with hedge funds. So anybody trading futures, FX, Equities, long, short, long only, extended a little bit to venture capital because venture capital is its own game. The sort of venture capital fund approach is really you have to start somewhere. So you start with say a $30 million venture capital fund. Hopefully, you identify some good investments if it's successful. And while that's successful, you then start the next fund where you can raise maybe $100 million, and then you start the next one where you can raise 300, 500, right? And so you'll make your money in subsequent funds, but you somehow have to survive and have the first fund do well. And again, you don't want to be doing all that stuff yourself. You want to sort of ideally partner with somebody who can provide you good infrastructure and deal with the stuff that allows you to focus.

Jennifer Bruno

And so, what are the features of Fundbox AI? Is it primarily focused on the registration, or do you cover other aspects of fund of fund services as well?

Scott Treloar

So, so we will partner with our trading partner, our sort of VC partner. We we will essentially be the fund manager, but we can't do anything without our sort of partners. But we'll take the regulatory sort of responsibility for the fund, and our role, in a sense, is not to do the trading or the risk management, even, but actually is really to provide the oversight so that the fund is operating the way it's been represented. To investors, it's operating and it's done efficiently. So what we can do, we will set up the fund. If it's a new trading fund that can be set up really for $10,000, a lot of the infrastructure is already in place. We just need to understand a little bit of what you're trying to do. Spin up a new vehicle and it's there, and then we'll run the fund with service providers. You know we have existing service providers, administrators, auditors, that and corporate secretary and things, directors that people need. But you know we can sort of switch them in and out. So if somebody wants to have a particular prime broker for for their fund or a particular administrator, that's that's easy. We can just onboard them, and run that. So, so so it becomes very straightforward, plug and play in a sense, right? Tell us what you're trying to build. We'll set it up, get it going, and you know, within a month, you know, if we're both efficient, we can have the first trade happening.

Jennifer Bruno

That was my next question. How long does it take? And so, you know, could be a month, could be could be longer on average. Is it about that long, or what's the average time it takes to get them up and running?

Scott Treloar

Yeah, yeah. I mean, so to put in context, to set up your own fund, firstly, you'd have to have a license, which might right now where we are, that's a sort of nine to 12 month process, and extending a little bit. But then you have to kind of do all these things that you're not really used to, right? How do I contract with the service providers? Which are the right service providers? Is that sort of fee structure for that administrator right? Can I? Where do I find directors to to take some risk and sit on the board of my fund? And you know, lawyers. Which lawyers can give me the legal infrastructure for the fund at a price that doesn't kind of kill me? And so we've already done that, and we kind of are quite good at doing that. And we also don't have any. We don't. We don't charge any markup across any of this. So really, we sort of try to work as best on the side of our sort of fund manager partner. We we want to find the lowest cost or service providers that meet the sort of quality that that they're comfortable with, and because we've done it a lot, we can just get it done efficiently. So you know, it might otherwise take people six to 12 months to really get a fund up and running. As I said, we can we can, if we really want to push, we can get get it operating within a month, or but at most probably two months.

Jennifer Bruno

And so, what is the process for the fund manager? Let's say they contact you. the The process. How do they do? They just sort of hand over the reins to you for a period of time, or what's the the process?

Scott Treloar

So no, we'll process to really onboard. We'll give them a link. We we systematize everything to keep costs low. They'll sort of start to fill in some information. We have existing legal documents, so the information they kind of complete in these online forms feed into the legal docs. You know, and so for example, if I'm setting up a new trading fund, I need to define my sort of target return objectives. I need to talk a bit about how I'm going to do my risk management, what sort of volatility I'm expecting what instruments I'm trading, and we sort of capture that and put that into an existing fund document. We kind of agree that that's fine. We can then go to the statutory board here to create the new fund vehicle. We'll tell the MS regulator here that there's a new fund starting. The fund manager has to give us a name, and then they also later have to start to let us know who their sort of initial investors are, so that we can start to do some AML KYC on the investors to make sure that's fine. We'll then sort of get subscription documents in place, and then they can sort of put money into the fund. And then you know we'll, in parallel, be setting up connectivity with the brokers that we sort of jointly want to work with. Money will then be transferred. You know, under the administrators basically govern how things work, but you know, under the documents, the administrators and we will kind of transfer money to the broker accounts, and then you know, day one, first trade can happen.

Jennifer Bruno

And what are some common mistakes that managers make in this process that you would say, you know, this or that could really slow the process, or this is where managers can get hung up unnecessarily. What would you say are the pitfalls to avoid?

Scott Treloar

I think the view would sometimes managers will come in and they'll sort of say, "Listen, I need tier one service providers. I need the." Expensive lawyers. I need the best audit group because otherwise people won't take me seriously. But what happens? And we can do that. But what happens is you end up just spending a lot of money. And when people start a fund, you're not really going to be bringing in a half a billion dollars from a large institutional investing. You're going to be going from friends and family and some friendly family offices and high net worth individuals, and so you need service providers that are good, robust. You know, people have sort of heard of them. They're not a two-man shop down the street, but you don't want the really expensive ones at the start. You can, you know, every if every couple of years, it's okay to sort of upgrade your service providers. But the idea is to sort of really start. Don't take too long to get going to get, you know, value for money service providers on board. That just allows you to get started, build a track record, and then, and then you know, with a track record, you can now go out and start to talk to talk to people. It's it's hard to talk to people. This is my great fund. I'm I'm about. I'm going to set it up. It's going to be real, and people will listen, but they won't do anything until you kind of at least have a fund and you've started a bit of training, and they can sort of see a little bit of track record. Then it's a lot easier. So, in a sense, get going relatively early. So that's probably avoid the high cost service providers.

Jennifer Bruno

Right. I've been hearing that a lot lately. That it's just sure. That's great if you can do that, but it's a a barrier often to getting going, and that's not good. So thank you for reaffirming that. I've heard that before. Yeah,

Scott Treloar

it's true, and in a sense, you know, we're sort of seeing, you know, hedge fund launches over the longer run declining just because it's getting harder. You'll still have these kind of high profile. Somebody spins out of Millennium, and they're given half a billion dollars, get going, or they've got this great pedigree out of an existing fund, and so it looks like it's sort of going all right. But but that is not really enabling a new, interesting generation of managers that have perhaps more creative ways to trade markets. It's sort of in a sense perpetuating the existing, you know, ecosystem of very large people with larger managers with pedigrees getting money from large allocators. Whereas really, we want you know because it's harder to get started these days. Banks don't have proprietary trading in the same level they sort of used to. You can't start a fund until you sort of have bigger chunks of money. It's just not obvious how to get going, and in which case you sort of tend to lose that that pipeline of of good talent coming into the environment.

Jennifer Bruno

Right, and how would you say the process of working with Fundbox AI. How does that? How do the costs differ? I know obviously that the whole point is to make fund registration and operation more accessible to smaller managers. So, what would you say is the actual cost, average cost benefit of working with your program versus the traditional way.

Scott Treloar

I mean, I think it's increasingly very difficult to set up a standalone fund if you haven't got somebody to give you $100 million, and even $100 million, maybe you charge one and a half percent management fee, so maybe you have a million and a half dollars in consistent revenue. But if you have a team of five, you know people are expensive. Your compliance and legal people are expensive. That's gone already. So, so even $100 million, you're struggling to do well, right? You really, and that, in a sense, is good and bad. You know, if you have a $10 billion, then you can sit there comfortably, and your management fees pay for everything, and you can, you know, go skiing and stuff.

Jennifer Bruno

No one starts with that. Yeah.

Scott Treloar

No, that's right. But but you're sort of kind of comfortable in a sense, right? This is the challenge. This is the challenge of you know emerging managers versus the established incumbents. The established incumbents, you you wonder about their motivation because you know is. Edge still there if you're if you're comfortable right so so investors like that they want emerging managers to be not desperately poor and struggling to survive but they want them to be thinking more about performance which comes from you know having your cost base kind of okay, but but focusing on how you can deliver better performance for your customers. Whereas large, you know, managers managing billions and 10s of billions, I don't think they just have that motivation. So so we want this emerging manager space to to do well. And allocators will also say to us, listen, we're really interested in that space. We just can't invest because you know we're just not confident in their infrastructure and how they're put together. And and so we, to a certain extent, can sort of be a more mature sort of father figure in a sense, mother figure of of these sort of smaller managers. We provide the oversight. We're not motivated to to to trade and punt and double up if if things are going badly. So we're the sort of grown up in the room in a sense. So investors can sort of feel okay. So there's because hedge funds can be tricky, right? That if you're a hedge fund manager, you're the boss, right? You don't. You might have a risk manager, but the risk manager is employed by you, right? So even if the risk manager tries to tell you not to do something, you just you know get another risk manager or something. So so so so that a standalone fund has that risk, and you will definitely see funds get into trouble like that because you know normally the hedge fund manager is a dominant personality, right? They're not really that consensus oriented because that's sort of the style a little bit, and there's not a countervailing force, you know, if if they're the principal. So, so in a sense, partnering with managers just provides a sort of more balance. What we're sort of saying is, let's make sure everything is being run as represented to investors. We're creating the universe. We agreed with our risk controls are sort of in place. We're not breaching things. Free trade checks are sort of happening, and and then the manager is almost more comfortable as well, right? Because they sort of there's a bit less pressure on them. They just you know say, listen, I have to do with the best I can do, and they're not able to do anything more than than the investors would really like.

Jennifer Bruno

Speaking of investors and allocators, do you provide any sort of cap intro, or or not so much.

Scott Treloar

No, no. Fund box is the infrastructure, but what we are doing because we sort of noticed this, we are looking to build out and work with particularly digital marketing partners, so ways to to more effectively let investors know the sort of types of funds that are available and those characteristics, and and because we are sort of building infrastructure across multiple funds, we can provide more analytics and better transparency because we build once and roll it out over multiple funds, so we can provide this sort of transparency in analytics. And we have, for example, our what we call the fact fact box, which is a widget-based fact sheet. So each manager can sort of design and just move widgets. I want to show risk exposures, and I want to show performance curve, and I want to show the historical returns, and I want to show my factor exposures, and sort of build that, and that becomes a sort of online sheet that they can just provide to investors as a link, and investors can PDF it if they want. So we think there's a lot of interesting ways under a digital and digital operating model to create better connectivity between investors and our underlying funds and fund managers. But we're it's still a little it's early in that game. But we're pretty interested in trying to work on better ways to to do that because it's a big one, right?

Jennifer Bruno

That's a big. That's a really helpful type of service to provide. It's almost like a performance database mechanism where you know there are those platforms where managers provide their monthly their month end returns, and then investors come to to check out all these different funds. So that's really if if you're adding that on at some point, I would think. And plus, just creating those fund fact sheet materials for them, that's super helpful. That's helpful to investors as well. Investors are looking for that information, so that's that'll be a great add-on at some point.

Scott Treloar

We we also have full trade level information because they trade, they send signals to us, and we all sort of execute via the relevant brokers. So we've we've already built trade level analytics. Just look at bets and frequency and bet sizes and winds and and all sorts of things that you can sort of extract from a sort of higher granularity look at the information, which we can provide in two ways. One is we can actually push it back to the manager to say, listen, this is what we're sort of seeing, and this might be helpful for you in terms of maybe sort of some of your position sizing, or you know, working on your your your exits from positions because maybe it looks like your exits are sort of losing your money a little bit. But similarly, we can provide much richer analytics through to investors, so we can talk about you know they say you know these are market neutral and they're sort of not that market neutral. These are the sort of tail correlations. This is a sort of drawdown you know intraday or daily drawdown rather than just a sort of monthly return. So so yeah, I did potentially we can provide much better analytics, and that's a heavy lift. That's a heavy lift.

But but you can do it once in a sense, right? And try to then we can sort of generalize it across and and offer it across lots of lots of managers and lots of investors. So there's a sort of logic, sort of economies of scope in terms of doing it once and letting everybody use it.

Jennifer Bruno

What type of technology do you use to do that? Because you had mentioned that you you you know you want to move away from Excel and so forth. So how does that work?

Scott Treloar

So not that I would understand.

Jennifer Bruno

It's okay. I'll give you a summary.

Scott Treloar

I hear a simple summary. But you know, so all our technology lives in a sort of virtual private cloud in Amazon. We have schedulers that run and give us oversight in terms of when we should be doing things. So I've got to load the benchmark data. We'll do that once a day. We kind of have a dashboards for that. We have a portal that has multiple views on our sort of data. The fund manager partners will be able to see sort of their trades and positions and P&L and the capital they've got. We'll also have a view for investors, so each investor has a sort of login, and they can sort of see what's happened to you know their specific capital, and all the documents are there, and so it becomes that where we're trying to get to is you know right now what will happen is an investor will invest into a fund, and once a month or once a quarter, I'll get a PDF that says this is what happened, but they don't really know much what happened between them. Whereas for us, we can give investors; they can basically log in and say, "Okay, so I made $6,000 yesterday, and I lost $2,000 today, and and my exposure is across these asset classes, and this is the product, and here are my all my sort of subscription documents, and and here's the commentary from each from the manager each month on what's happened. So so it becomes a sort of two way engagement because where we want to get to is move from products to solutions in a sense, right? The industry is built around salespeople flogging products, but investors really need solutions. So you need a kind of two-way thing rather than a one-way information stream. So, so part of building a digital operating model is we can now start to give our fund manager partners and our investors' insights they can sort of look in and potentially even sort of provide information back into us for how things are going to, you know, what's what's happening. So, for example, our manager might we might have a quarterly fee structure with them. So instead of a say, can you please now email me an invoice? That'll that'll just be on the portal. So they'll have a look and say, yeah, I agree with that number. Tick the box, and the sort of money will be paid automatically into this account. So that sort of digital approach just strips out a whole lot of cost. It speeds everything up, and it also starts to innovate in terms of the relationship with the manager, innovate in terms of the relationship with the with the investors and and also the service providers. So we're trying to bring the industry into the 21st century.

Jennifer Bruno

Right, those efficiencies are very compelling. You know, to the managers and to the allocators. I you know that's that's definitely. Compelling. Where are you seeing most of your new business coming from in terms of fund managers? Where are they based? Are are you having a? Are they coming from Asia, or where are they primarily? Where are they based?

Scott Treloar

It's more a function of of where they're based anyway. So an extent is lobbed in the U.S. so we work with U.S. managers, European managers, Asian managers. But it's just a sort of there are fewer Asian managers, there are more European managers, and there's a lot of U.S. managers. And we don't care. They'll, you know, you could have an Asian manager trading U.S. equities or a U.S. manager Trading Japan long short equities, something like that. European managers trading commodity futures. And what are doesn't really matter for us.

Jennifer Bruno

Right, right. What would you say are the typical costs of your service on average?

Scott Treloar

Okay, so if you want to get started setting up a new fund, well, we'll say $10,000, $5,000 to pay a little bit of legals, $5,000 just sits there because in the event that things don't pan out, you have to shut the fund down. You can't really reuse it because it's got a track record that nobody wants, and shutting down a company or a fund, you just need to do. That's a process, so that gets you the fund. Operating the fund, we think we're down to around 20 to $25,000. It's a bare minimum of costs to the fund or the service providers, administrator, audit directors' fees, filing tax, and that sort of thing.

Jennifer Bruno

Would you say is that annually or on it annually? Okay, great. And so, my last question is: What do you think helps an asset manager be successful from your perspective? What's the most important thing?

Scott Treloar

So, I mean, we look at a lot of managers. We've, we've, in various parts of what we do, looked at over 200 managers, and we just try to run a process where we try to understand what they are. They'll sort of come in and fill out some forms, and we'll ask them questions about, you know, how do you handle risk, and what's your universe, and can we see your your trading history, all that sort of stuff. What we find is, is is I think the you know or at least let me characterize what I would expect from or we sort of see from successful managers. One is they typically have a product market understanding, right? They they don't come in as a technologist saying I'm going to trade futures. They usually have to have done it, and because financial markets are fiddly, annoying things with different holidays and ways to trap you up, and it's full of people just waiting for you to get it wrong to to take advantage of you. So you need to sort of understand that product market space that you're going after. You need some technology to leverage and to sort of improve what you know to provide leverage to what you're doing, right? You don't really want to be with a pencil and paper going, "I'm going to buy this or sell that. But the third thing is, you need to somehow be contrarian or some sort of edge, doing something different. We'll ask people, "Do you have a different? You know, what's the information source that you're using for your trading? What's the modeling or the sort of framework that you use to to make your trade? So somewhere in that thing has to be some contrarianness or some idiosyncrasy, because otherwise you'll be doing what everybody else is doing, and and there's no alpha in doing what everybody else is doing. So, so so managers, so and these people who are like that are often a little bit unusual, right? themselves, they don't naturally fit into it. So you know, and for they don't want to be part of the big firm, right? They there's a reason they want to start set up and run their own fund. It's it's because they don't want to be part of you know J.P. Morgan because they don't fit. They're sort of you know like that, and we like that as well too. We're also saying to the industry, you know, this we think this is not good. We think there's a much better way to do this, and we want to sort of shake things up. So, so you sort of we're looking for people who are a bit like that, and we can handle, you know, interesting people and characters. We really data driven. We just look at the data and say, okay, fine. You're sending us the signals. If there's alpha, there's alpha. What's your? What's your? What's your? Did you go to an Ivy League school? We don't care what gender or race are. We don't care. Just let's understand that there's. Some sort of edge, and you're able to to deliver some some some extra return for our investors.

Jennifer Bruno

That is the bottom line. I tell and I tell my manager clients all the time. Like, what what is your point of differentiation? What is your competitive edge? Because that's what allocators are looking for. They want to know that you're doing something different for sure. Yeah, that's super important. So, how does a manager find you? What is the where? What tell us your website?

Scott Treloar

Fundbox AI. Great. Alsonnificent.com, and you can also kind of get there from there, or you just look me up, Scott Trelawri. You'll find me. I'm I'm very noisy on LinkedIn, so um, you can sort of message me me there, but but we have a we try to be transparent and and open, so so we try to put out as much information as we can about how things work, and we can always do better. But but Funbox AO is a kind of starting point for that.

Jennifer Bruno

Fantastic. Well, thank you so much for joining me today, Scott. And this is really helpful for smaller managers who want access to, you know, non non U.S. registration and so forth. So that's really really helpful. Great, thank you.

Have a story worth telling?

Managers, allocators, advisors: episodes are 30 relaxed minutes, recorded remotely, and made to share.

Pitch yourself as a guest

New conversations, twice a month.

One email when each episode drops: the story, the best line, and the listen link.

Subscribe