capital firsthand.

Home  /  Episodes

Manager Profiles

Edward Chin & Thejas Nalval

CEO & CIO, Parataxis Capital Management

June 2023 · 41 min

Institutional discipline in a market that had none.

Edward Chin and Thejas Nalval built Parataxis to bring multi-strategy, risk-managed discipline to digital assets, through the drawdowns that wiped out less careful firms. The co-founders talk about the firm's evolution since 2019, managing counterparty risk during market stress, and what growing allocator interest in digital assets actually looks like from the manager's side.

In this conversation

  • Multi-strategy investing across digital-asset inefficiencies
  • Operational and counterparty risk management under stress
  • What institutional allocators ask before touching the asset class
  • Macro correlation, regulation, and the road ahead

Transcript

Produced from the audio of this episode and cleaned for readability — no wording was changed. Guests state their own figures and opinions on the record; those statements belong to the speaker, not to the show or its host.

5,617 words · 59 exchanges

Parataxis Capital's Multi-Strategy Approach

Jennifer Bruno

Welcome to Hedge Interview. This episode is part of the Manager Profiles series, which features distinguished asset managers with a unique approach in their strategy space. My guests today are Edward Chin and Thejas Nalval of Parataxis Capital Management, a multi-strategy investment firm focused on the digital asset sector. Ed is the CEO of Parataxis and, prior to co-founding the firm with Thejas, he was an investment banker at two digital asset merchant banks: Galaxy Digital and Element Group. Ed began his career at Lehman Brothers and he spent 10 years as an investment banker, executing mergers and acquisitions and financing transactions across the Tech, Media and Telecom sectors. Thejas is the Chief Investment Officer of Parataxis and, prior to co-founding the firm, he was a portfolio manager at digital asset hedge fund Ledger Prime and he was head of asset management at the Element Group. Prior to joining the digital asset space, Thejas spent eight years at Goldman Sachs, most recently as a trader within the firm's macro trading group. Thank you both for joining me today.

Edward Chin

Thanks, Jennifer, for having us.

Thejas Nalval

Thanks for having us.

Jennifer Bruno

So first tell me about Parataxis and why you decided to develop your specific investment program.

Edward Chin

Yeah, we started Parataxis in late 2019. Coming out of the bear market of 2018, one of the things that we realized was that there was increasing interest and appetite from large, sophisticated investors across the institutional investment community looking to gain exposure to the sector, but what became clear was that a lot of the vehicles and wrappers for them to express that view weren't appropriate from a risk management perspective, and so the goal when we launched in late 2019 was to provide a risk managed institutional product that would apply traditional investment trading strategies to what we thought was still a nascent and growing market.

I would say one of the things that has evolved since then especially between 2019 and 2021, is that the discussions with our perspective allocator base and this includes not just high net worth or family offices, who've traditionally dabbled in digital assets, but increasingly pension funds, both private and public, endowments and foundations, was that the asset class was no longer not investable.

Instead of debating whether or not the asset class would be sustainable, continue to see growth and evolution, the discussions clearly changed to one of finding the appropriate type of vehicle to gain exposure to the space and to figure out how to size and manage that allocation. And so what we realized with that change in tone was that asset managers that were crypto native, that understood how to find opportunities across the space, were going to be very, very important, but increasingly, individuals that had come from traditional backgrounds, that think about risk management, I would say from a traditional perspective, were going to be absolutely necessary, given the operational complexities and the plethora of idiosyncratic risks as it relates to this specific asset class, and so we had decided at that point to launch the firm and develop vehicles to allow allocators to gain that type of exposure.

Jennifer Bruno

It's great that you understood that, because it's been really difficult or challenging, I think, for a lot of digital asset fund managers that want to attract institutional capital but struggle to because of the risk management element and just the resistance that typically comes up from institutional managers. So the fact that you developed a program that appeals to that group, you know, to the institutional world, is a real feather in your cap, and I guess what would you attribute that to, is it, how did you know how to get it right for that investor base?

Thejas Nalval

I think it's a function of the backgrounds we all come from. For myself, I spent most of my early career on a trading floor at a bank that focuses heavily on operations and risk management. I interacted on a daily basis with the largest endowments and sovereign wealth funds in the world, so you build up an understanding over time of what really matters to the largest and most sophisticated investors over time. And I can say the same story for each of us on the team. We all come from a background where risk management mattered. We were trained to think about things the right way, so the way in which we structured our company, the way in which we structured our culture, was with that mindset at the forefront.

Jennifer Bruno

And tell me about how you guys met. How did this, how did Parataxis come together? How did you meet?

Edward Chin

Yeah, so I'll give you my version and hopefully it lines up with Thejas' version as well. But so we met at the Element Group. The Element Group was an early merchant bank, focused on the space, with tremendous growth and market share at the time. I was on the private side, running the advisory business at the time. I identified early- stage disruptive technologies across Web 3 and crypto, raising capital for these businesses and often times investing alongside. On the other side of the Chinese wall, facing the public markets and the firm's asset management business was Thejas.

We were the two folks that were in the New York satellite office at the time. The headquarters was based out of Southern California. And so, managing that office and teams here. Although there was a separation as it related to the types of capital and investors and opportunities that we were looking at, we were more or less in contact on a daily basis and realized that we had this shared interest and perspective on the market and the opportunities that lied before us. But the market itself and the products itself had to evolve in order to meet demand from, as Thejas described, a much more sophisticated investor base.

Jennifer Bruno

How did you decide you were ready to pull that together?

Thejas Nalval

I think timing is everything, especially with this asset class. When we met, the crypto markets were experiencing its first major bear market in 2018. Timing wasn't exactly right to launch a fund. I think we, like Ed said, we both come from very similar backgrounds. We both are about the same age, have young families, had similar experiences before joining digital asset space, and we both have more of an entrepreneur bug. We wanted to launch something in the space. And so I knew for me where my strengths were, where my weaknesses were, and I knew I needed to partner up with somebody who complimented my skillset and hopefully I do so for Ed. So we both knew we wanted to do something, but timing was everything And really at the end of 2019, the timing was much better, and it was at that point we decided to launch the company.

Edward Chin

Yeah, that being said, folks, that we were crazy launching into the start of the global pandemic, and so there are obviously a number of challenges, but in hindsight it was probably the best time to be launching.

Jennifer Bruno

Definitely. 2018 was definitely a bear market, so that's a great time to gather your you know, get it together and figure out what exactly you know. It's a good time to plan While things are not great and then come out when the market starts expanding. So that definitely was really great timing. So tell me about your investment program and your approach. What are your focus areas within the digital asset space?

Thejas Nalval

Sure. So I think we, even though we come from backgrounds where, personally, i've interacted with, with, with, with products and asset classes that have been very mature, we recognize that crypto, digital assets it's still a very nascent asset class. The market is inefficient, the market structure is still still being architected And therefore, in our view, there are multiple ways to earn a return, multiple ways to create value in this asset class. So that is that's one of one of our core beliefs as a company. So what that translates to within paratax is we look at opportunities that that rely on trend following, for instance, both directionally, long and short, maybe relative value, pairing one name against another. We look for opportunities that may require some more fundamental bottoms up, type of research into space, involving tokens, involving the equity of early stage projects. We look at statistical arbitrage opportunities. Again, this market is very inefficient. As a result, there are, there are patterns we can recognize intraday that we can capitalize on and again earn us a source of return.

Jennifer Bruno

We look at adventure and strategies.

Thejas Nalval

We also look at. You know, our own version of smart beta strategies. Again, it's, it's, i'd say as a as a in our core. We're a multi strategy type of organization.

Jennifer Bruno

And that really is a multi strategy approach.

Thejas Nalval

Again, it stems from the fact that the market is inefficient, it'll, in our view, it'll remain inefficient for some time And, unlike the equities market, i think, the crypto markets tend to evolve and reinvent themselves every 18 months or so. In our view, if you really if you just pigeonhole yourself into one source of return profile because there's an arbitrage opportunity, chances are, in 18 months, 24 months, that arbitrage opportunity will cease to exist And it'll be very difficult to exist as a fund. So, in our view, the only way to really manifest and secure longevity as a fund, as a company in the space, is to is to really lead with this multi strategy approach.

The Importance of Risk Management

Jennifer Bruno

So that plays nicely into risk management as well. I would think it does, it does.

Thejas Nalval

And that would be remiss if if I said there was no risk in this asset class. There is, and risk at that is is, i think, a function of it being a brand new asset class. You know, effectively the whole financial ecosystem that we've known and interacted with with for decades as being architected within blockchain and digital assets. So a lot of the strategies, a lot of the, the ways of looking at this world are very novel, and with that comes risk. Our job as a, as a, as a fund manager, is to is to manage that risk, is to mitigate that risks where we can, and that how we do that, you know we've. We tend to categorize risk based on, i guess, market risk and portfolio risk, and that's the easy part. You know we can. We use some very similar risk management techniques that any traditional fund manager would use in terms of how we, how we construct our portfolio, the level of risk that we're comfortable with given a certain stuff strategy, how we manage our long and short exposures our our net delta positions when we hedge.

But then we have to pay special attention to you, i'd say more of the operational risks that exist And that's how we trade, where we trade, who our counterparties are, where we have exposure to And I think we pay special attention to to that part of the risk management category only because you know it's very clear that who you traded with and where you'd exposure to in 2022, it really mattered.

And I think you know because we paid special attention to where we traded and how we traded, and you know we were able to, we were able to survive and not expose our investors to a lot of the original pitfalls that some of our peers and, unfortunately, had access had exposure to.

Jennifer Bruno

That's so important. You know, institutional investors I interview and speak with have said over and over again it's great if you make me money, but, above all, you know you have to preserve capital. You have to know how to do that. So it's really you know, and going through a tough year like 2022 or any challenging period is just a feather on your cap that shows that you weather the storm. You know how to get through, because there's been so much attrition in your space right and and you're still standing. So that's extremely important and, given the, you know the breadth of your, the tools and the tactics that you apply. Tell me about your team and your organization how, how big, how many people are involved in the parataxis operation yeah, given the multi-strat approach, it does require a combination of different skill sets.

Edward Chin

I think the overarching requirements, though, or what we described up front, is that the folks have to be crypto native, so it's not just looking at the price of a digital asset and trading that, but but have an understanding of the fundamental drivers, because, at the end of the day, price should at some point reflect fundamentals, whether that's growth or adoption, or or or or some other metric. And then the second requirement is the, the traditional background, so that we are all on the same page as it relates to thinking about building an institutional product and thinking about risk the right way, and so we have a team of seven today four investment professionals, uh, two non-investment professionals and we do have a, a separate bitcoin mining business, and so we have a. Bitcoin mining operations lead there that that business is interesting because it allows us to delve into the other parts of the ecosystem, whether it relates to infrastructure stack or understanding how mining pools operate, the effect of hash rates, difficulty and what that would mean for price, and and, frankly, it does impact how we think about our strategies at times as well. And so, outside of tages and myself, we have a third partner, julien gropp, also from a traditional background, much more tech, banking and private equity focus. He spent time at kkr and lasard before joining us and, and i would say um, we've used 2022 to not only survive but but, to you know, map out the next stage of our growth. We've been able to expand and hire on our team. We've brought on a quant researcher, um, who spent a large part of it, a part of his time, at various quant hedge funds, including aqr who's building out a? lot of the quant systematic strategies for us and then given, given the the non-investment related workload as it relates to managing an asset management business controller, head of ops and and somebody that's dedicated to the IR function and so that allows us to have a team that can be pretty much dedicated to managing our our LP's assets the right way and to find new and interesting opportunities but also kind of manage and run all the other parts of of of managing a business in this space so, speaking of 2022, what are all asset managers evolve.

Lessons Learned in Digital Asset Investing

Jennifer Bruno

Everybody has lessons learned, no matter what strategy space you're in. So what would you say are some of the key lessons learned that you're taking with you into or hurdles you've overcome? however you want to frame it um as as we move further into this year, i could not.

Thejas Nalval

I can kick that off with a few. I think i think one thing, one thing we knew going into a year like 2022 that you know it was very demonstrated, it was valuable was just communicating with, with investors and communicating with stakeholders, especially when there is um, when, when, when there are events that are occurring in the marketplace and information is getting disseminated in real time over social media, over twitter. Um, you know, you know all it's. It's clear that all of our investors are seeing certain headlines and how they interpret that is uh, is important and providing some context is important. So, you know, we did a lot of, we did a lot of communication last year, especially last summer, especially during the you know, the debacle of ftx in november.

Um, and it was largely you know it was largely just to set investors at ease. Um, you know, and there is. You know there were weeks at a time it seemed like we were just putting out a brand new investor email, uh, just to tell everybody it was. You know, we had an exposure to xyz kind of party, you know. You know this is how we're thinking about the world. And just, you know, in a, in a normal market environment, that type of communication may be, uh, over gala times, but, you know, especially in a world like you lived in last year, i think, um, it allowed us to, um, really demonstrate how we, how we, thought about the world when, uh, things are bad. But it also, i think, it gave a lot of our largest investors, um, you know, more confidence in us and so, yeah, um, i, i, i don't add um that as it relates to the markets.

Edward Chin

You can't be an ideologue in this space, and so the notion that you should sell everything and just go into digital assets because it's gonna take over the world it's not the right way to be thinking about the space And, unfortunately, a lot of stakeholders in this ecosystem their decision-making is binary. I'd say the thing that we took away from 2022 specifically is that macro matters and the macro environment, macro volatility matters, and so I feel like 2022 was a year where high yield was down 15, 20, 25% at one point. Equities obviously had a drawdown as well, and we're starting to see cracks in commercial real estate in other parts of the credit system. That's a function of the macro environment. It obviously had an impact on digital assets as well, and so, although we always have a view towards the fundamental drivers and the crypto native narratives that we think will lead to growth and adoption, and allow these persistent arbitrage trading opportunities to exist, we have to take a step back and understand the asset class in light of the wider macro picture as well.

Jennifer Bruno

I think that's really important for every strategy. You just kind of can't ignore the big picture of what's going on. I mean even your investors. They wanna know what you're thinking during those periods and understand what your approach is. So it's definitely important And, tajas, your background being part of the Goldman Sachs macro trading group particularly obviously Lens. That experience lends itself to this, to what you're doing now and paying attention to all of those things. I would think.

Thejas Nalval

No, absolutely. Just to piggyback on what Ed said, when we entered the crypto space in 2017, there really weren't any institutional investors in the space at large. There were a few funds, but the space was largely invested by high net worth individuals, maybe some family offices. There were no pension funds. there were no corporates buying the coin or buying really any digital asset, and even the players that were the market participants were largely crypto native. So this is the first cycle where you saw a bit of a transition of traditional investors coming into the space Pretty meaningfully. you saw traditional market participants, market makers, brokers, actually entering the digital asset space either largely through the futures market, which does have a correlated effect on spot volumes, And so the macro having an impact on the digital asset space. it shouldn't have come as a shock to anyone. I think it is especially when you have an overlap in market participants that now view digital assets as part of a multi-asset portfolio. So there's going to be some causality between asset classes, And it's something that we especially when we see macro headlines. we always try to understand what the impact could be, short-term and long-term, for our asset class and also within our funds.

Jennifer Bruno

And how have things changed in terms of institutional money participation in the digital asset space since last year into this year? What are you witnessing as far as their interest and interest in the digital asset space?

Edward Chin

Yeah, I think going back two years, a number of institutional allocators had identified this asset class as one that they need exposure to, So I think folks have moved beyond.

Will Bitcoin disappear to? this is here to stay, but we need to be able to manage volatility and get the right type of exposure, and so 2022, i felt like it was going to be one of the greatest fundraising years, at least for our fund, but all that was kind of put on pause when FTX happened. I think FTX was one of the largest exchanges in the world. If you look at their equity cap table, you had a number of prominent individuals that vetted that opportunity and still weren't able to identify certain risks, and so, for a lot of institutional allocators that had already vetted the sector, figured out the type of exposure that they wanted, they had to go pencils down.

I think that's changing right now. We're seeing a thought in. conversations have gone back towards identifying the survivors from last year and trying to sift through the best way to get exposure to an ecosystem that has over 20,000 cryptocurrencies available out there, and so that requires working with managers that breathe this day in and day out. But what we're realizing one thing that has changed is a move away from, i think, just getting passive exposure, given the volatility, and more towards managed strategies, whether it be low wall, high, sharp type of strategy, something that may have directional or quantitative components to it, and so that's a bit exciting because we get to help allocators figure out and create products that are bespoke to the specific type of exposure that they're looking for And, to the extent that we can apply traditional investment strategies and risk management practices to provide that exposure.

Jennifer Bruno

we think it's a great opportunity on both sides. And what are you focused on right now in terms of the macro environment?

Thejas Nalval

So one of the views that we had at the start of the year, or at the end of last year or closely, was that there would be a meaningful amount of supply pressure in the digital asset market, both from folks likely It's more of a year end dynamic where you see some rebalancing occur across the space, both within crypto native funds and also within traditional funds that may have some crypto exposure. Our view was that we would see a sharp mean reversion to start the year. Just given any time there is a disproportionate amount of buying or selling, usually there is a nice reversion to the mean, especially with something as inefficient as crypto is, and we've seen that evidenced already in Q1.

Most of the market was up anywhere from 50 to sometimes even 150% for anything in Q1 itself.

Jennifer Bruno

And that's just purely a market structural dynamic that existed.

Thejas Nalval

Our view now is that a lot of the force selling that took place is behind us force selling from either leverage that existed in the ecosystem, exposure to the Block Fies, the Celsiuses, the FTXes of the world, and so the market's behaving a bit more rational today.

We are, though, paying attention to what's happening, say less on the macro side, but more on a regulatory side, both here in the US and globally.

It's something that we're paying attention to in real time because, obviously, a lot of it has an effect on I would say, less about prices, but more of an effect on perceived behaviors of different participants in the ecosystem And, as it relates back to the macro space, whether we're not a macro fund, but we are paying attention to what the Fed is doing and what we think the Fed will, where they'll land at the end of the year and how that's going to impact traditional risk assets and what impact it's going to naturally have on Bitcoin and the rest of the ecosystem.

There is a bit of a cycle. We do think, as our view, that if the Fed does pivot eventually, if there is a shift in language, that will likely trigger capital to flow back into what traditionally has had the highest beta, and that's been digital assets, been Bitcoin, it's been Ethereum, and so we should see a little bit of a sharp uptick right off in the back of any sort of language that would assign a pivot. It's not going to happen anytime soon, but likely at some point, either later this year, early next year is where we see a bit of an inflection point, i think it lines up very nicely with the having schedule that Bitcoin has.

Every four years Bitcoin's the amount of Bitcoin mined in a block is cut in half, and historically that has always been the start of a secular blow for crypto. So a lot of the forces are lining up for the end of this year and early next year to be a much more constructive market environment for disaster.

Jennifer Bruno

And hopefully the worst is behind us as far as interest rate hikes, because with a bunch all in the fall of last year had a really strong impact on the markets and everything contracted And I feel like my observation is that the Fed looks back and is like, ooh, i guess we need to ease. We need not ease but approach this a little more gently so that the markets don't get crushed like they did last fall. The whole economy, i don't mean just the capital markets, but it had such a harsh effect that hopefully the worst is behind us and even future hikes will be staggered.

Edward Chin

Yeah, Yeah. I think the other thing that's really important is that the size of the net is always evolving because the narratives surrounding the macro picture and, I would say, separate asset classes is always evolving, If you think about the narrative surrounding digital assets and specifically Bitcoin. last year it revolved around BTC being somewhat like gold and serving as an inflation hedge, and that narrative was clearly invalidated And I think part of the resurgence and interest in the asset class is BTC as a source of having a hedge against monetary debasement, and so that's going to definitely impact the macro. We have a macro overlay and, as Tage described, always have a view towards what the Fed may be doing. what is the money supply doing? what are interest rates? what does the outlook look like for rates? but that's an overlay. At the end of the day, we do still have a bottom-to-bottom approach and that's a crypto-native part of this asset class.

It's not just the fund flows in the market microstructure. Those are really important for a number of our stat-arp strategies and trend-following relative-value strategies, but there's just tremendous growth that still exists in the space and disruption, and so, by taking a bottom-to-bottom approach, it does allow us to sift through the landscape of, as I described, 20,000 digital assets to find the best ways to gain that type of exposure once growth resumes.

Jennifer Bruno

And so, lastly, what's the best way developments are you looking forward to in terms of you know, your growth at parataxis, or macro developments or things on the horizon that you're that are you're positively looking forward to?

Edward Chin

So we're excited because we have a multi-strat approach, and what that means is that, as Tage just described, depending upon what the market is doing or what the macro environment looks like, we can overweight or underweight different types of exposures in order to kind of get a composite, risk-adjusted return profile attract, risk-adjusted return profile. I think what's exciting for us is that there are a lot of allocators that are doing a lot of work on the space, and the way that we know that is that, instead of just digging into the sector at a high level, they're trying to understand specifically how some of these ARBs work and in different ways to gain exposure that replicate strategies in Treadfy but have higher returns, oftentimes, just given the market is more nascent, it is more inefficient, and so that's a bit exciting for us to explore, because we can parcel out specific exposures and provide that through different types of structures that are most relevant and help for prospective allocators.

The one other thing I would say is the market does feel like 2019, almost four years ago, going into a halving year. Back then it was in 2020. Obviously we're blindsided by the pandemic, but 2018 was one of the worst bear markets on record for the sector and had anybody taken the time to look underneath the hood, they would have seen that there was still tremendous technological innovation adoption taking place and 2019 felt like the year of consolidation before before growth resumed.

Our view is that, to the extent that that is a similar cycle that we're in, hopefully 2024 we'll have a much more accommodative macro backdrop because it's clear that that that the innovators in the space are building and, at some point, that building an adoption should be reflected in the price of digital assets.

Digital Assets and Allocators' Perception

Jennifer Bruno

And it's great that allocators as well are expanding their understanding of the digital asset space and their more open-minded going forward. I think that also helps because, again, weathering this period and seeing that digital assets aren't just going to go away because of a difficult period probably helps bolster the whole digital asset sector as far as being a real meaningful place to consider allocating, given how that sector behaves and that it's here to stay and that there's so much opportunity yet to discover, for it's just definitely under allocated to and probably will be for a while.

Thejas Nalval

Yeah, and just to add to that, jennifer, i think you know a few years ago, when allocators were researching the space, usually the trend was to what trend the dynamic was? there was usually a junior person on the team that understood the space and they were given ownership of. Hey, just figure out, if this is you know, this is something we should pay attention to, and this was, you know, four or five years ago. Those junior people have now been promoted and usually now what we're seeing is that they're in a decision maker seat and when we speak to allocators, the conversation isn't you know, what is bitcoin, what is blockchain? it is is very crypto native, as we're getting deep into the weeds, and whether it be DeFi, whether it be NFTs, whether it be infrastructure plays, and these are very, very these are very interesting conversations for us too, because you know we're having we're speaking intelligently about, about areas of the ecosystem that sometimes goes underserved in traditional media. So it's clear that allocators have a very strong thesis on the space.

It just goes back to timing. I think there will be a a timing component to where it becomes, where the opportunity cost of not being involved is actually greater than just, you know, sitting on the sidelines and so, and so I think I think we're excited for when that timing element does shift, and I think for us as a company too. And when we started Pairtaxis you know it was just adding myself, and it was largely a our thinking was you know, let's, let's build this. It was a very field of dreams. Ask, you know, let's build it, they will come. Whereas now we have a very strong team, we have a very capable team.

You know there are folks on our on our team that are smarter than and I myself. That's yeah and that's. You know we have the right people and that's almost a force multiplier as it relates to just being being a company in the space. And so now you know when they're, when we do transition to that moment where allocators start entering a space in in a in a meaningful way, you know they will come and we can build it. We can build whatever product or you know vehicle you know they'd like, and we couldn't do that three years ago. And it's because we have the right team. So I'm really excited for for that fantastic.

Jennifer Bruno

Well, that's really exciting and it's great that those conversations have evolved and the market has. You know, the digital asset, space has evolved. So it's really, even though, even though the environment might still be a little challenging, the fact that so many other things have evolved, you know, just speaks to the opportunity in in the sector. So thank you both so much for participating today and being here to tell us about para taxes and for for folks that want more information about para taxes capital. You can visit their website at para taxes dot i o. And again, thanks so much, guys. It's been great having you here. Great thanks, thanks.

Jennifer all right.

Have a story worth telling?

Managers, allocators, advisors: episodes are 30 relaxed minutes, recorded remotely, and made to share.

Pitch yourself as a guest

New conversations, twice a month.

One email when each episode drops: the story, the best line, and the listen link.

Subscribe