Jeff Tumolo evaluates managers for TAG Associates, a multi-family office, and his bar is a sustainable, differentiated process, not last year's number. This conversation covers how TAG sources and qualifies managers, where emerging managers fit in the allocation, and his read on blockchain, AI, and ESG strategies at the time.
Produced from the audio of this episode and cleaned for readability — no wording was changed. Guests state their own figures and opinions on the record; those statements belong to the speaker, not to the show or its host.
Jennifer Bruno
Welcome to Hedge Interview. I'm your host Jennifer Bruno, and today on the Investor Views series, I'm speaking with Jeff Tumolo. Jeff is the chief investment strategist at Tag Associates, a multifamily office located in New York, with more than 8 billion in assets under management, at Tag Associates, Jeff develops the firm's firm-wide macro strategy and the firm's tactical strategies. He's the portfolio manager for client accounts, and he's the portfolio manager for Tag's distressed debt funds. Jeff is also a member of Tag's investment committee. He has been with Tag Associates since 2000, and before that, Jeff was a senior analyst at Schwab Investment Management for their fund of funds products. Jeff earned his Bachelor of Science from Cornell University, and he earned his MBA from Cornell's Johnson School. Thank you for joining us today, Jeff. I'm really looking forward to learning about your experience at TAG and your insight in your insights on the capital allocation process.
Jeff Tumolo
Thanks for having me.
Jennifer Bruno
So, tell us about TAG and your role at the firm. Give us a little feel for what type of firm
Jeff Tumolo
TAG is. TAG is a multi-client family office formed in 1983, so we've been in the multi-client business for quite a while. I joined the firm in 1999. We are a full-service family office in that we do everything from accounting, taxes, estate planning, trust administration, as well as asset management, we we have, as you said, a little over 8 billion in assets under management, and we service over 110 clients.
Jennifer Bruno
And what type of investments do you evaluate? What what's what are what are your primary holdings? Would you say?
Jeff Tumolo
Well, one of the things that that makes Tag a little bit unique is 1/3 of our assets are invested in alternatives. That was driven initially from the fact that many of our first clients were first generation wealth and had large legacy assets that they carried over with them. We've developed a deep and strong team, and have a long history of investing in alternatives. So, 1/3 of our assets are in alternatives; the other two thirds are in traditional stocks and bonds.
Jennifer Bruno
And so, for those alternative assets, what would you say is your primary criteria for making an allocation decision? I mean, obviously, there has to be some of the you know performance and track record. But how would what are what's important to tag as far as making an allocation?
Jeff Tumolo
I think the most important thing in choosing any manager is that the process in which they generate excess return is a sustainable process, and that the area, the capital markets that they're trying to to extract that excess return, has a sustainable or a definable inefficiency that they can continue to take advantage of.
Jennifer Bruno
How much does it matter to you that they have sort of a unique or some kind of competitive edge.
Jeff Tumolo
Depending on the strategy and the asset class, it always matters that that our managers have some edge over over the the typical manager or over an index. But depending on the strategy, that would require you know differing levels of expertise and differentiation. So if it's a mortgage arbitrage strategy, that requires a high level of sophistication and and and a deep understanding of some pretty esoteric statistics and and and other measurements. If it's a large cap growth manager, there's going to be less differentiation in in sophistication, but maybe differentiation in terms of vision or or views on the market.
Jennifer Bruno
And what types of alternative funds do you include? Are there do do you have a broad array? Are there typical strategies that you tend to lean towards?
Jeff Tumolo
Very broad array. The vast majority of our alternative investments is in absolute return strategies. The next largest would be hedged equity strategies. Although across all of private equity, I think those numbers might be somewhat similar, and then as we get into some of the more spicy things like biotech and venture capital, that's generally going to be a much smaller piece of what we do.
Jennifer Bruno
What areas do you think are really saturated?
Jeff Tumolo
What areas? I think are saturated strategy
Jennifer Bruno
spaces.
Jeff Tumolo
Hedged equity is more and more difficult to find differentiated strategies, and I think, particularly in the United States, there are probably too many managers in the long short space.
Jennifer Bruno
Do you consider emerging managers?
Jeff Tumolo
We do.
Jennifer Bruno
And how do they fit into the scheme of things, the portfolio? How do you evaluate emerging managers? How do where do they fit?
Jeff Tumolo
Well, TAG has over 700 manager meetings a year throughout our research group. Some of those are are just follow-ups with existing managers, but the vast majority are looking at new managers. And in particular, we like to find talent that has yet to develop a track record that would catch the attention of the broader competitive landscape. So we're looking for managers who have a great pedigree and a process that we think is going to lead to differentiation, and we have established a number of farm teams over the years to make small allocations to these new managers and get involved early and understand their process a little bit better. That's been a very successful effort when taken in its entirety. We've been able to demonstrate that it's added value, and and those that graduate to be full positions are often some of our best finds.
Jennifer Bruno
It's sort of a needle in the haystack to find, you know, a rising star that's really worth, you know, worth the allocation. How do you typically find those rising stars?
Jeff Tumolo
You know, that that's sourced from a number of different places. I would say the most successful sourcing mechanism is through existing managers or others in the the investment world whose opinions we respect, and we are introduced to a young rising star. That said, we're of course also combing the databases all the time to look for something that's a bit unusual and might be worth our digging a little bit deeper,
Jennifer Bruno
right? And how much do you typically allocate to an emerging manager?
Jeff Tumolo
Generally between one and 5 million, depending on the strategy and the size of their fund.
Jennifer Bruno
Okay. Do you shifting gears a little bit? How do you approach, if at all, ESG or impact funds.
Jeff Tumolo
Our our efforts in ESG are largely client driven. It's it's really up to them to determine how they want to approach ESG. I think in general, there's two approaches. One is to make money in the most effective way possible, and and and decide on how one wants to allocate their charitable giving. Some clients have expressed interest in ESG. I personally work with a number of clients who've divested from fossil fuels, and we've come up with an interesting alternative strategy to get that energy exposure in their portfolios.
Jennifer Bruno
Do you think that that's, in your experience, is that a growing area, or has it been sort of maintaining? I think
Jeff Tumolo
it is a growing area, and as we have taken on younger and younger clients, it's come up more and more in conversation.
Jennifer Bruno
And what about what about other newer spaces like blockchain technology and cryptocurrency? Is that any? Are you looking at any of those funds, or is that still too new yet?
Jeff Tumolo
But blockchain uses up quite a bit of bandwidth for a very very small part of the investment universe. I think I am definitely of the belief that blockchain technology is revolutionary in some sense. There's those that say it's as revolutionary as the internet, and I think that's a little bit of an extreme view. On the other hand, cryptocurrencies are very, very difficult to analyze or value. There aren't any fundamental inputs to really assess whether something's inexpensive or properly priced. So our efforts, which have been fairly modest to date have been investing in private equity funds that are focused on businesses that use blockchain technology to make advances or to disrupt existing industries.
Jennifer Bruno
Okay, and are there any other areas that you would that you're researching or evaluating that would. New for tag.
Jeff Tumolo
New for tag. I think we're always looking at things that are off the beaten track. There aren't any that come to mind right now. That like what about
Jennifer Bruno
AI?
Jeff Tumolo
AI is a difficult thing to invest in because the definition is different depending on which industry or area of the market you're looking at. With respect to quantitative strategies, we do have one investment in an AI-driven quantitative equity strategy. It's been very successful. We'd love to develop that relationship more, but it's it's so early in in the onset of artificial intelligence that it's kind of difficult to rely on a short track record and make assumptions about future performance.
Jennifer Bruno
Tell us about an investment pitch success story where you were truly impressed, so that asset managers can get a feel for what it takes to impress you. What would be a success? What did they do differently, or just in general that would make you feel impressed?
Jeff Tumolo
Yeah, I think you know a lot of that is it comes out of the dialog you have with the individual. But as a general point, those that have documented their process in their clearly in their existing efforts to run money, but in their previous positions, and can demonstrate a long history of having a consistent, proven process for identifying good investments. Those those managers give us a lot of comfort, particularly if it's an emerging manager where we don't have a lot of track record to rely on. It's it's all about the the consistency and repeatability of the process.
Jennifer Bruno
And what would be for an emerging manager? What would be sort of a minimum track record that you would consider?
Jeff Tumolo
We have considered. We have rarely, and I'd have to think hard if we've ever done a brand new fund, but we will consider track records of less than one year. What we do require, absolutely and positively, is that there be a first year audit. So, if it's a partial year track record, but that partial year track record has been audited, then that'll be the first step for us to take a look at a particular manager, so long as we are comfortable once again with the process, we're we're comfortable with investing in managers whose track records may not be as long as the average holding a tag.
Jennifer Bruno
And how do you feel? I've had asset emerging managers ask me, "Well, what if I have hypothetical results?
Jeff Tumolo
There are ways to audit hypothetical results, and if they've been audited in that manner, we'll look at them. If they have not, we dissist them completely.
Jennifer Bruno
And so, on the conversely, tell us about like a million-dollar mistake. Somebody who blew it. What did they do that made you just say no, not going to happen.
Jeff Tumolo
Well, there's an easy answer to that. We we do background checks on on all of our managers, and one manager had lied about their educational history.
Jennifer Bruno
Oh wow!
Jeff Tumolo
And that was was thrown out immediately. Turned out that that saved us from a poor performer as well, but but but certainly you know integrity is an important piece of the due diligence puzzle, and and that didn't pass the test. So that that's the one that comes immediately to mind.
Jennifer Bruno
And so, what's the number one thing you would advise an asset manager to do before they contact you if they were reaching out to you, maybe not. Obviously, if somebody's been referred to you, that's a little easier. But if someone's reaching out, what's the number one thing you would advise if they were sort of a cold outreach to you?
Jeff Tumolo
That's a very good question. I I think to somehow define what the distinguishing aspect is of their strategy in a very clear and concise manner, why they're different than others in their particular space, and how they are going to prove that to me in a meeting?
Jennifer Bruno
Great. Again,
Jeff Tumolo
I think comes back to to the process.
Jennifer Bruno
And so, lastly, this is my last question: What are you looking forward to next year, or as this year comes to a close? And this could be some of my guests. I. They answer this how whatever comes to mind either could be something with your kids or something professionally.
Jeff Tumolo
I would say what immediately comes to mind is some sort of resolution or clarity on the trade war mess that we're currently in. I think that's been a real headwind for for both people in the operating business side of the economy, as well as those of us in the investment community, that uncertainty is is a large cloud over over the over the future, and I hope we can get some kind of a resolution, or at least some clarity, in the next 12 months.
Jennifer Bruno
Yeah, I hope so too. You're not the only one who's answered that question with that answer, so it's definitely on a lot of money managers' minds. But thank you so much for your time today. Your insights are very helpful, and I know the asset managers watching this episode will appreciate understanding these insights and taking them to heart as they try to raise money. So thank you so much for your time today.
Jeff Tumolo
Thanks very much for having me.
Managers, allocators, advisors: episodes are 30 relaxed minutes, recorded remotely, and made to share.
Pitch yourself as a guestOne email when each episode drops: the story, the best line, and the listen link.
Subscribe